How Cooking Method Affects Flavor

With so many different methods, it's hard to know where to start when you get into cooking. Even for experienced cooks, it’s hard to pick the right cooking method for every dish, vegetable, or cut of meat. This is especially true if you are trying to get away from following recipes and are interested in learning the science of cooking. 

Every cooking method has a unique effect on the taste of food on a chemical level based on multiple factors. Studies show that cooking method has a significant impact on how much people enjoy what they’re eating.

That’s why we’ve created a brief guide on different cooking methods. We believe you can learn to cook anything you want and make it delicious - and that the best way for you to feel comfortable doing that is to explore all the different combinations of cooking methods, preparation, and ingredients available to you. That way you can learn why recipes are constructed the way they are, and what the right tools and appliances are for you so that you can make food you really like, tailored to your palate.

The Basic Effects of Heat

Food’s reaction to the type of heat you’re applying is fundamental to the cooking process. Let’s review before we get to talking about cooking methods:

Pyrolysis

Pyrolysis is the breaking down of any material because of heat. The process of wood burning is pyrolysis, and so is the creation of charcoal. 

The easiest way to think about pyrolysis with food is that too much of it burns it - but the right amount can caramelize food through pyrolysis of sugar, or provide a perfect char to the outside of a smoked brisket. It’s all about burning something the right amount. Too much pyrolysis will give foods unpleasant, acrid burnt flavors.

Caramelization

Caramelization is the process that gives many foods a golden brown color and a rich, slightly nutty, butter-like flavor. It occurs when sugars are broken down by heat exposure. Caramelization can occur with any type of sugar, whether natural to the food you’re cooking, like caramelized onions, or added to it in the form of a glaze, or marinade.

Technically, caramelization is a form of pyrolysis since it occurs because of the breaking down of sugars due to heat. Caramelization is an effect of dry, not wet, heat.

The Maillard Reaction

The Maillard reaction is the primary process responsible for producing the flavors of browned foods. Everything from brown bread crust to steak sears to the distinctive dark color and strong aroma of roasted coffee beans is caused by the Maillard reaction.

The Maillard reaction is caused by the breakdown of sugars and amino acids in a low-moisture environment. The combination of reduced sugars and amino acids creates melanoidins. Many recipes and cooking methods rely on the Maillard reaction for flavor by using high enough temperatures so that the amino acids and sugars can combine.

Wet vs Dry Heat

The type of heat used is one of the major differences between cooking methods.

Wet heat uses liquid or steam to cook food either by using water, stock, beer, or other liquids. The more liquid used, the more tender the result. More flavor tends to come from these additives or from the combination of flavors compared to dry heat cooking methods.

Dry heat uses hot air, conductive metal, or direct contact to heat food. This usually results in higher temperatures that allow pyrolysis, caramelization, and the Maillard reaction to occur. This can result in deeper more distinct flavors developing from the meat itself compared to more moist heat. It’s important to be careful of drying out or burning food when using dry heat.

Grilling

One of our favorite meat cooking methods, even among all the different methods of cooking steak. Grilling is a flexible and flavorful way to cook just about anything. 

An important consideration of grilling is that the fuel source will play a part in defining the final flavor. Propane and natural gas grills don’t add any extra flavor. Pellet grills and traditional barbecue using wood fires to add smokiness of varying intensity from mild woods like maple to strong, earthy mesquite. When charcoal burns it releases guaiacol which adds a rich, smoky flavor similar to pellets, but with added notes of bacon.

Ideal for Cooks Who: Want to maximize flavor, especially for meat, who like being outdoors, or who love to host

What it Does: Applies direct heat through the air and flame instead of using water or a pan to conduct heat - ideal for getting all three flavor-causing reactions in your food; pyrolysis, caramelization, and the Maillard reaction

Heat Type: Dry

Best Uses: Meats, veggies, fish, just about anything, the flexibility of barbecuing is why it's one of the oldest cooking methods

To add extra moisture and flavor, many grillers use glazes or marinades to counterbalance the dry heat. Added liquids and sugars can also help produce a stronger Maillard reaction or caramelization.

Smoking

Does grilling just not add enough flavor for you? Smoking foods may be right up your alley. Whereas grilling is a direct heat cooking method, smoking relies on indirect heat to slow-cook food over a long period. The results of smoking food are similarly affected by the choice of fuel, from more flavorful woods and charcoal to more neutral gas or electric options.

Ideal for Cooks Who: Want smoky flavor and who have space and time for slow cooks

What it Does: Tenderizes meat like a wet heat cooking method, flavors and lets meat shine like a dry heat method

Heat Type: Dry

Best Uses: Slow cooking tough cuts of meat to make them tender, without using a moist heat that would result in less exterior pyrolysis

Boiling

Little to no additional flavor is created by boiling food. One simple reason is that the moisture inhibits caramelization and the Maillard reaction. The relatively short cook times and moderate temperatures used also make these reactions weaker when they do occur. One thing to keep in mind about boiling food is that water can leach flavor and nutrients from what you’re cooking.

A related cooking method, sous vide, is an interesting combination cooking method. Sous vide involves placing food into airtight bags before placing them into heated water. They are then slow-cooked on low heat until done. The lack of direct moisture can allow for caramelization and the Maillard reaction to occur, while the slow, low-heat cook produces tender results.

Ideal for Cooks Who: Need to cook vegetables, potatoes, or grains

What it Does: Heated water softens and cooks food, making it ideal for tough proteins and starchy foods like potatoes

Heat Type: Wet

Best Uses: Softening tough starchy foods, grains like pasta or rice, or things like eggs that have a protective outer layer to prevent nutrient and flavor loss

Roasting

Oven roasting shares traits with other methods, but there are a few key differences that distinguish it. Like grilling, roasting involves heating the ambient air temperature around food to cook it, and like smoking, it does so in a closed environment to trap heat and cook slowly and indirectly. Due to the lack of smoke from wood or charcoal, the flavor of roasted food comes more directly from the food and the preparation method used, rather than the cooking process. 

Since roasting lacks the direct flame of grilling which leads to pyrolysis, the main flavor added by the cooking process comes from caramelization and the Maillard reaction. This effect can be increased by adding extra sugars and amino acids, which is part of why many recommend adding glazes or oils before roasting vegetables.

Ideal for Cooks Who: Want a crispy exterior with plenty of flavor and who are most comfortable using an oven

What it Does: Heats the air inside the oven to cook food at high temperatures for short periods of time, while also promoting reactions that increase flavor

Heat Type: Dry

Best Uses: Vegetables, single dish recipes, large cuts of meat, or whole birds like Thanksgiving turkeys

Baking

Roasting’s slower, cooler cousin is intended for cooking foods that lack structure and solidity. Perfect for making bread, cookies, muffins, casseroles, or anything else that starts as a dough or changes significantly during the cooking process. The lower, consistent temperature allows heat to cook and penetrate internally, while still creating a crispy exterior or crust from the Maillard reaction.

Ideal for Cooks who: Are creating baked goods and side dishes to pair with a main course or for casseroles and hot dishes

What it Does: Heats the air in a sealed oven, which conducts heat through the baking dish or sheet and creates a Maillard reaction on exposed surfaces.

Heat Type: Dry

Best Uses: Breads, muffins, confections, single pan or dish recipes

Braising

The braising cooking method combines both wet and dry heat. First, the food is browned or seared and then slow-cooked in liquid until tender. The idea is to have the best of both worlds - the deep flavor of a pan sear for the Maillard reaction with the tenderness and savoriness of an oven slow-cook.

Ideal for Cooks Who: Like to have their cake and eat it too, who are cooking indoors without a grill or smoker but still want maximum flavor, or who picked up a tougher cut of meat on sale and want to make the most of it

What it Does: Tenderizes due to liquid submersion, low heat, and slow cooking time, while still getting the added flavor from caramelization and the Maillard reaction due to the initial sear and dry heat inside the oven

Heat Type: Wet and dry

Best Uses: Meals where a large or tough cut of meat is center stage and single dish recipes in a Dutch oven or deep, oven-safe pan

Stewing

Stewing is a classic cooking method that tends to create a rich combination of flavors. More moist cooking methods, like stewing, inhibit caramelization, which is part of why many recipes will call for browning or searing meat before stewing.

Stews and braises tend to differ in that stews use smaller, uniform cuts of meat while braises use larger cuts. Stews also tend to use more liquid and are cooked on the stove, rather than in the oven.

Ideal for Cooks Who: Want to cook with wet heat on a stovetop without losing nutrients or flavor to boiling, since the conductive liquid is part of the dish

What it Does: Cooks food slowly using heated liquid, blending ingredient flavors to create a cohesive final taste

Heat Type: Wet

Best Uses: Creating flavor medleys, tenderizing tough ingredients like pot roast, making use of random ingredients

Pan Frying

It’s no secret that the trusty pan is one of the most flexible ways to cook pretty much anything. So we hope you won’t mind that we’re cheating a little bit with this one to cover a few different closely related cooking methods. 

Whether pan-frying steaks, browning beef before a braise, caramelizing vegetables, sautéing, or stir-frying the pan is a key part of any cook’s toolkit. By using direct, dry heat, the pan fry method has virtually unlimited flexibility.

Ideal for Cooks Who: Want to keep it simple with direct heat and a flat surface, or who just want an excuse to break out their cast iron

What it Does: Just about anything you need it to, but it might not be the best choice for every situation

Heat Type: Dry

Best Uses: Searing, browning, caramelization, jack-of-all-trades

Key Takeaways

One of the most important things to keep in mind when you cook is how the method you use affects the final flavor. If a recipe doesn’t have a cooking method that aligns with your palate, it may be time to explore other options.

It’s essential to make sure you’re comfortable with your tools and appliances, not just for the best results, but for your safety. Understanding how you’re cooking, why you’re cooking that way, and the equipment you’re using are the three keys to great flavor and a safe cookout.

Additionally, don’t get discouraged! We know cooking is hard, but like Bob Ross says, “Talent is pursued interest. In other words, anything that you’re willing to practice, you can do.”

Feel the urge to get cooking? We encourage you to visit our showroom at 455 W. South St, Lincoln, NE to see our full selection or to browse our online grilling and cooking inventory.

Consider subscribing to our newsletter below if you want to learn more about cooking or to receive updates about new products and sales.